Comparative Review of Informed Consent as a Legal Safeguard in Healthcare: Perspectives from Indonesia and Others Countries
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.54518/rh.5.4.2025.717Keywords:
Comparative Law, Healthcare, Informed Consent, Legal SafeguardAbstract
Informed consent serves as a fundamental ethical and legal mechanism to uphold patient autonomy and safeguard against medical malpractice. This evolving concept provides an opportunity to assess the weaknesses and effectiveness of informed consent mechanisms as a form of legal protection in Indonesia, particularly in comparison to the legal systems of other countries. This paper aims to compare the role of informed consent as a legal safeguard in healthcare services in Indonesia and other countries. This study employed a comparative legal research method using both normative-comparative and functional approaches, supported by literature searches across four major electronic databases. The included materials consist of peer-reviewed empirical studies, legal analyses, policy reports, and case studies. In Indonesia, informed consent is governed by various legal instruments, including the newly enacted Law No. 17 of 2023. However, implementation faces challenges related to cultural values, paternalistic practices, and limited health literacy. In comparison, systems in the UK, Germany, and the US emphasize individual autonomy and standardized documentation, whereas Indonesia continues to struggle with systemic and socio-cultural barriers that compromise consent quality. In many developing countries, collective decision-making norms and resource constraints further hinder compliance with international standards. Meanwhile, developed countries face challenges related to complexity, variability in practice, and the influence of advanced technologies on patient comprehension. Informed consent is a vital legal instrument in healthcare, but its implementation is heavily influenced by the legal structure, cultural context, and institutional capacity of each country. A culturally adaptive approach to informed consent, alongside capacity strengthening, simplification of informational materials, and the use of communication technologies, is essential to ensure ethically sound and legally effective patient protection.
Downloads
References
Abraham, Z., & Mathias, M. (2024). The practice of informed consent among patients undergoing major surgeries at a regional referral hospital in Dar es Salaam Tanzania. Medical Journal of Zambia, 51(1), 40–48.
Addissie, A., Davey, G., Newport, M. J., Addissie, T., MacGregor, H., Feleke, Y., & Farsides, B. (2014). A mixed-methods study on perceptions towards use of Rapid Ethical Assessment to improve informed consent processes for health research in a low-income setting. BMC Medical Ethics, 15(1), 1–12.
Andayani, A., & Kurniawan, A. (2023). Juridical review of legal protection of health personnel according to international and national law. Policy, Law, Notary and Regulatory Issues (Polri), 2(4), 383–391.
Awangga, A. (2023). Perlindungan hukum terhadap pasien rawat inap berdasarkan Undang-Undang Nomor 44 Tahun 2009 tentang Rumah Sakit. Collegium Studiosum Journal, 6(1), 69–80.
Balasingam, U. (2022). Case note: Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board and the resulting aftermath. Journal of Health and Translational Medicine (JUMMEC), 25(1), 134–139.
Bandewar, S. (2003). Cultural barriers, “competence” and informed consent in population-based surveys. Issues in Medical Ethics, 11(2), 49–51.
Bolcato, V., Franzetti, C., Fassina, G., Basile, G., Martinez, R. M., & Tronconi, L. P. (2024). Comparative study on informed consent regulation in health care among Italy, France, United Kingdom, Nordic Countries, Germany, and Spain. Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine, 103(1), 102-114.
Brunvand, S., & Bouwman, J. (2018). A global perspective. Science and Children, 55(8), 50–55.
Chaar, S., Oliver, E., Ali, R., Abou Khalil, I., Elias, J., Meksassi, B., et al. (2025). Developing guidelines for culturally relevant informed consent: An example from Lebanon. PLOS Mental Health, 2(4), 174-197.
Chima, S. C. (2018). An investigation of informed consent in clinical practice in South Africa. Pretoria: University of South Africa.
Cipta, D. A., Andoko, D., Theja, A., Utama, A. V. E., Hendrik, H., William, et al. (2024). Culturally sensitive patient-centered healthcare: A focus on health behavior modification in low and middle-income nations—Insights from Indonesia. Frontiers in Medicine, 11(1), 1–7.
Creed-Kanashiro, H., Oreé, B., Scurrah, M., Gil, A., & Penny, M. (2005). Conducting research in developing countries: Experiences of the informed consent process from community studies in Peru. Journal of Nutrition, 135(4), 925–928.
Desdiani, D., Mulatsih, S., & Puspandari, D. A. (2024). Implementation of respect for autonomy in hospital services within the Indonesia national health insurance system. National Journal of Community Medicine, 15(10), 830–841.
Ede, O., Obadaseraye, O. R., Anichi, I., Mbaeze, C., Udemezue, C. O., Basil-Nwachuku, C., et al. (2024). Examining the adequacy of preoperative informed consent in a developing country: Challenges in the era of surgical specialisation. Developing World Bioethics, 24(2), 296–301.
Günther, C. (2024). Artificial intelligence, patient autonomy and informed consent (1st ed., Vol. 81). Baden-Baden: Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft.
Hatta, M., Khairunnisa, C., & Wahyuni, S. (2024). Communication in health care services: An overview of the legal position of informed consent. International Journal of Law, Social Science and Humanities, 1(1), 1–8.
Hernoko, A. Y., Anand, G., Dharmadji, A. G., & Ramadhan, C. (2020). The anatomy of informed consent that provides legal protection for every party. Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, 390(1), 6–12.
Indina, F. (2024). Kajian yuridis persetujuan tindakan medis (informed consent) dalam perspektif Undang-Undang No 17 Tahun 2023 tentang Kesehatan. Jurnal Cahaya Mandalika, 3(11), 633–638.
Irawati, A. C., Kristiningrum, W., & Andayani, A. (2020). Pendampingan perlindungan hukum pelayanan kesehatan melalui informed consent. Indonesian Journal of Community Empowerment (IJCE), 2(2), 75–82.
Jaman, U. B., Priyana, Y., & Ar-Rahmany, M. (2023). Pengaruh kebijakan hukum terhadap perlindungan hak asasi manusia di negara berkembang: Studi pada negara berkembang. Jurnal Hukum dan HAM Wara Sains, 2(7), 556–565.
Jawa, N. A., Boyd, J. G., Maslove, D. M., Scott, S. H., & Silver, S. A. (2023). Informed consent practices in clinical research: Present and future. Postgraduate Medical Journal, 99(1175), 1033–1042.
Krogstad, D. J., Diop, S., Diallo, A., Mzayek, F., Keating, J., Koita, O. A., & Touré, Y. T. (2010). Informed consent in international research: The rationale for different approaches. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 83(4), 743–747.
Kurniawan, F., Aspan, H., & Andoko, A. (2024). A juridical review of informed consent based on Law Number 17 of 2023 concerning health as a replacement for Law Number 36 of 2009. Bengkoelen Justice: Jurnal Ilmu Hukum, 14(1), 85–100.
Kurniawan, I. G. A., & Chandra, A. (2024). The civil law aspects of informed consent to medical procedures. SASI, 30(3), 326–338.
Lazuardi, I., & Marwiyah, S. (2023). Analysis of informed consent as the legal protection of physician relationships and patients in malpractice cases. Policy, Law, Notary and Regulatory Issues (Polri), 2(4), 327–338.
Hidig, S. M., & Nour, A. A. (2024). Ensuring informed consent in low-income settings: Opinion piece. World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 22(1), 898–900.
Mayer, K. F. (2002). The process of obtaining informed patient consent. Nursing Times, 98(31), 30–31.
Masyuri, R. I., Setioboedi, D., Mashdurohatun, A., & Kadarmo, D. A. (2024). Towards equitable healthcare: Redesigning informed consent regulations. Journal of Ecohumanism, 3(8), 8518–8524.
McCormack, D. J., Gulati, A., & Mangwani, J. (2018). Informed consent: A global perspective. Bone and Joint Journal, 100B(6), 687–692.
Memon, R., Asif, M., Shah, B. A., Kiran, T., Khoso, A. B., Tofique, S., et al. (2024). Clinicians’ experiences of obtaining informed consent for research and treatment: A nested qualitative study from Pakistan. BMC Medical Ethics, 25(1), 1–9.
Mentzelopoulos, S. D., Couper, K., Van de Voorde, P., Druwé, P., Blom, M., Perkins, G. D., et al. (2021). European Resuscitation Council guidelines 2021: Ethics of resuscitation and end of life decisions. Resuscitation, 161(1), 408–432.
Mihiretu, M. M., Bekele, E., Ayele, K., Asmare, L., Bayou, F. D., Arefaynie, M., et al. (2024). Patient knowledge of surgical informed consent and shared decision-making process among surgical patients in Ethiopia: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Patient Safety in Surgery, 18(1), 1–10.
Millum, J., & Bromwich, D. (2021). Informed consent: What must be disclosed and what must be understood? American Journal of Bioethics, 21(5), 46–58.
Milo, C. (2022). Informed consent: An empty promise? A comparative analysis between Italy and England, Wales, and Scotland. Medical Law International, 22(2), 147–166.
Morton, S., Janula, M., Quarto, C., & Trenfield, S. (2024). Informed consent: Do we have an obligation to double check? British Journal of Anaesthesia, 133(6), 1350–1351.
Mubarak, R. H., & Zarzani, T. R. (2024). Legal review of the implementation of informed consent in high-risk medical procedures in Indonesia based on Health Law No. 17 of 2023. Law Sinergy Conference 1(1), 263–271.
Nahler, G. (2009). Dictionary of pharmaceutical medicine. Vienna: Springer.
Orzechowski, M., Woniak, K., Timmermann, C., & Steger, F. (2021). Normative framework of informed consent in clinical research in Germany, Poland, and Russia. BMC Medical Ethics, 22(1), 1–10.
Pakpahan, K., Widiyani, H., Veronica, V., & Kartika, S. (2021). Perbandingan perlindungan hukum pasien korban malpraktek bedah plastik di Indonesia dan Korea Selatan. Jurnal IUS Kajian Hukum dan Keadilan, 9(1), 221–235.
Pittalis, C., Sackey, C., Okeny, P., Nandi, B., & Gajewski, J. (2024). Surgical informed consent practices and influencing factors in sub-Saharan Africa: A scoping review of the literature. BMJ Quality and Safety, 33(10), 653–662.
Pont, A. V., Taufiq, M., & Purwoto, A. (2025). Legal and ethical aspects of informed consent in BPJS health emergency services. International Journal of Health, Economics, and Social Sciences, 7(1), 190–195.
Prihandono, I., Widiati, E. P., & Valčiukas, J. (2023). Free, prior, informed consent as a legal principle and its link to the right to freedom of conscience. International Comparative Jurisprudence, 9(2), 182–196.
Putra, P. A. P. E., Kartika, I. G. A. P., & Kuswardhani, R. T. (2024). The role of informed consent in medical disputes at state university hospitals. Unram Law Review, 5(2), 1–10.
Rajkumar, C. A., Bello, O., McInerney, A., Tilsted, H. H., Johnson, V., Fovino, L. N., et al. (2022). Consenting practices in interventional cardiology: An analysis from the European Association of Percutaneous Cardiovascular Interventions (EAPCI). European Heart Journal, 43(2), 203-222.
Risdawati, I. (2024). Legal aspects in implementing an informed consent system in patient health practices. International Journal of Society and Law, 2(1), 115–126.
Shah, P., Thornton, I., Kopitnik, N. L., & Hipskind, J. E. (2024). Informed consent. In StatPearls. Treasure Island, FL: StatPearls Publishing.
Siregar, B. H., Andini, T. Z., Siregar, R., Rahma, H., Harahap, M. S., Devi, D. P., et al. (2024). Perbandingan pengaturan tata hukum antara Indonesia dan Amerika Serikat. As-Syirkah: Islamic Economics & Financial Journal, 3(3), 508–521.
Stultiëns, L., Dierickx, K., Nys, H., Goffin, T., & Borry, P. (2007). Minors and informed consent: A comparative approach. European Journal of Health Law, 14(1), 21–46.
Sugiarti, I. (2014). Perbandingan hukum informed consent Indonesia dan Amerika Serikat. Syiar Hukum, 12(3), 245–268.
Symons, T. J., Zeps, N., Myles, P. S., Morris, J. M., & Sessler, D. I. (2020). International policy frameworks for consent in minimal-risk pragmatic trials. Anesthesiology, 132(1), 1–10.
Tarantini, G., Fraccaro, C., Porzionato, A., Van Mieghem, N., Treede, H., Shammas, N., et al. (2025). Informed consent and shared decision-making in modern medicine: Case-based approach, current gaps and practical proposal. American Journal of Cardiology, 241(1), 77–83.
Willis, L. (2003). The ethics of research related to healthcare in developing countries. Medicine, Conflict and Survival, 19(1), 74-89.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Fuji Restu Firma, Elim Jusri, Asep Sapsudin
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
